Holiday Shopping Trust Outlook

Holiday Shopping Trust Outlook

The holiday trust gap

Holiday Shopping Trust Outlook

Holiday Shopping Trust Outlook

We surveyed 1,921 online shoppers on every step from choosing a store to getting a refund. Here’s where trust breaks down, and what merchants can do to build it back.

Survey conducted by The Harris Poll for Seel among 1,921 US adults who shopped online in the past six months, October 22 to 24, 2026.

Survey conducted by The Harris Poll for Seel among 1,921 US adults who shopped online in the past six months, October 22 to 24, 2026.

Survey conducted by The Harris Poll for Seel among 1,921 US adults who shopped online in the past six months, October 22 to 24, 2026.

80%

80%

80%

4 in 5 online shoppers named at least one thing that would make them hesitate to buy a gift online this holiday.

KEY FINDINGS

KEY FINDINGS

KEY FINDINGS

4 in 5 shoppers would hesitate to buy a gift online this holiday

4 in 5 shoppers would hesitate to buy a gift online this holiday

4 in 5 shoppers would hesitate to buy a gift online this holiday

Holiday shoppers are looking for something that a price tag can’t necessarily answer on its own.

In an economy where every dollar is getting a second look, they’re looking for proof that a store will keep its word once the money has changed hands. Right now, many aren’t sure they’ll find it.

That doubt starts with the store itself: 1 in 3 hesitate to buy from a site they’ve never used, even when it’s the only place selling the item.

Close behind are worries about what happens after the gift is given:
1 in 4 worry the recipient would have to pay for return shipping, and nearly 1 in 4 aren’t sure the gift can be returned after the holidays.

Fortunately, shoppers are clear about what would ease that doubt, with 83% more likely to buy a gift online if they were certain it could be returned after the holidays, even without a receipt.

Top concerns about buying a gift online this holiday

Top concerns about buying a gift online this holiday

Top concerns about buying a gift online this holiday

Base: 1,921 US online shoppers

Base: 1,921 US online shoppers

Base: 1,921 US online shoppers

Buying from a site they’ve never used

Buying from a site they’ve never used

Buying from a site they’ve never used

Even when it’s the only place selling the item

Even when it’s the only place selling the item

Even when it’s the only place selling the item

35%

35%

35%

The recipient would pay for return shipping

The recipient would pay for return shipping

The recipient would pay for return shipping

26%

26%

26%

Not sure the gift could be returned after the holidays

Not sure the gift could be returned after the holidays

Not sure the gift could be returned after the holidays

24%

24%

24%

83%

would be more likely to buy a gift online if they were certain it could be returned after the holidays, even without a receipt. The fix is certainty.

would be more likely to buy a gift online if they were certain it could be returned after the holidays, even without a receipt. The fix is certainty.

This holiday season favors the stores shoppers already trust. That gives merchants two plays.

This holiday season favors the stores shoppers already trust. That gives merchants two plays.

This holiday season favors the stores shoppers already trust. That gives merchants two plays.

This season favors the stores shoppers already trust, which leaves merchants two plays. With loyal customers, reinforce that trust: make your return window and refund terms easy to find, and continue honoring them through January.

With new ones, give them what a price tag can’t. A first-time shopper can't see how you treat people after the sale, so show them in plain language before checkout.

IF YOU HAVE LOYAL CUSTOMERS

IF YOU HAVE LOYAL CUSTOMERS

IF YOU HAVE LOYAL CUSTOMERS

Protect that trust

Protect that trust

Protect that trust

Make your holiday return window and refund terms easy to find, and deliver on them in January.

Make your holiday return window and refund terms easy to find, and deliver on them in January.

IF YOU WANT NEW CUSTOMERS

IF YOU WANT NEW CUSTOMERS

IF YOU WANT NEW CUSTOMERS

Price alone won’t win them

Price alone won’t win them

Price alone won’t win them

Shoppers are vetting the store as much as the product. Show them you’ll hold up your end after checkout.

Shoppers are vetting the store as much as the product. Show them you’ll hold up your end after checkout.

The holiday shopper’s journey

The holiday shopper’s journey

Where trust breaks down, from first click to January refund

Where trust breaks down, from first click to January refund

Where trust breaks down, from first click to January refund

Stage 1

Stage 1

New store? The return policy is definitely on the shopping list

Before a first-time shopper pays, they have very little to go on. Nearly 1 in 5 struggled to tell whether a website was trustworthy at all, and the three most common frustrations of the past six months all come after the order is placed.

That’s why a return policy does so much work for a store nobody knows yet. It’s one of the few places a new store can show how it behaves after the sale, before the sale happens.

The three most common online shopping frustrations are all post-purchase

The three most common online shopping frustrations are all post-purchase

Base: 1,921 US adults who shopped online in the past six months. Share of shoppers who named each frustration in the past six months.

Base: 1,921 US adults who shopped online in the past six months. Share of shoppers who named each frustration in the past six months.

30%

30%

Delivery took longer than expected

Delivery took longer than expected

Delivery took longer than expected

25%

25%

Shipping costs were higher than expected

Shipping costs were higher than expected

Shipping costs were higher than expected

25%

25%

Unsure an item would fit or meet expectations

Unsure an item would fit or meet expectations

Unsure an item would fit or meet expectations

19%

19%

Nearly 1 in 5 struggled to tell whether a website was trustworthy

Nearly 1 in 5 struggled to tell whether a website was trustworthy

Frustration in the past six months. Within a few points for every age group.

Frustration in the past six months. Within a few points for every age group.

Frustration in the past six months. Within a few points for every age group.

Frustration in the past six months. Within a few points for every age group.

Stage 2

Stage 2

Shoppers will pay for certainty when it’s their choice

Shoppers will pay for certainty when it’s their choice

Shoppers will pay for certainty when it’s their choice

A store’s word is easy to give and hard to check. Most shoppers say they’d lean toward the store that offers a guarantee, something they can actually hold it to.

70%

70%

would be more likely to buy from a retailer offering a paid worry-free return option than an identical one that charges for return shipping

would be more likely to buy from a retailer offering a paid worry-free return option than an identical one that charges for return shipping

Most would also consider paying for it themselves. 61% would consider a small fee at checkout for worry-free returns, meaning free return shipping and a guaranteed refund. The interest is strongest among shoppers under 45 and parents of kids under 18 (more than three in four of each) and weakest among shoppers 65 and older (36%).

Would consider paying a small fee for worry-free returns

Would consider paying a small fee for worry-free returns

By age

By age

61%

61%

All online shoppers

All online shoppers

77%

77%

Ages 18 to 34

Ages 18 to 34

76%

76%

Ages 35 to 44

Ages 35 to 44

36%

36%

Ages 65 and older

Ages 65 and older

Dashed line: all online shoppers (61%)

Dashed line: all online shoppers (61%)

Would consider paying a small fee for worry-free returns

Would consider paying a small fee for worry-free returns

By parent status

By parent status

61%

61%

All online shoppers

All online shoppers

77%

77%

Parents of kids under 18

Parents of kids under 18

76%

76%

Non-parents

Non-parents

Dashed line: all online shoppers (61%)

Dashed line: all online shoppers (61%)

Parents are twice as likely to be much more likely to choose the worry-free retailer

Parents are twice as likely to be much more likely to choose the worry-free retailer

34% of parents vs. 17% of non-parents

34% of parents vs. 17% of non-parents

Much more likely, from the 70% question

Much more likely, from the 70% question

Stage 3

Stage 3

Nearly half of shoppers have fudged a return reason

Returning something is about as ordinary as online shopping gets, since 71% of shoppers did it in the past year. But the return is rarely the whole story.

Most returns come from what you’d expect: an item that didn’t fit, arrived damaged, or didn’t match its description. Other returns come from reasons retailers rarely hear, like an impulse buy, second thoughts about the spending, or needing the money back for bills. In fact, 47% have given a retailer a different reason for a return than the real one, which leaves merchants making sizing, inventory, and policy calls on an incomplete version of the story.

And some shoppers skip the return altogether. 63% have kept something they didn’t want because sending it back cost too much. That’s no return data, and a customer stuck with something they didn’t want. In both cases, the merchant is the last to know.


Why shoppers return: the reasons retailers hear, and the ones they rarely do

Why shoppers return: the reasons retailers hear, and the ones they rarely do

Share of online shoppers citing each reason for a return in the past year

Share of online shoppers citing each reason for a return in the past year

Retailers usually hear

Didn’t fit

Didn’t fit

26%

26%

Damaged or defective

Damaged or defective

22%

22%

Didn’t match description

Didn’t match description

22%

22%

Retailers rarely hear

Impulse buy

Impulse buy

12%

12%

Regretted spending

Regretted spending

10%

10%

Needed money for bills

Needed money for bills

9%

9%

47%

47%

have given a retailer a different reason for a return

have given a retailer a different reason for a return

have given a retailer a different reason for a return

47%

62% of shoppers 18 to 34

62% of shoppers 18 to 34

65% of parents

65% of parents

63%

63%

kept something they didn’t want because returning cost too much

kept something they didn’t want because returning cost too much

kept something they didn’t want because returning cost too much

63%

75% of parents

75% of parents

71% returned something in the past year

71% returned something in the past year

Stage 4

Stage 4

"Pending" is a long word when money is tight

Between the day a return ships and the day the refund lands, the shopper’s money is sitting with the store. With two in three US adults living paycheck to paycheck, according to PYMNTS Intelligence, that wait lands on a tight budget. 63% of shoppers say waiting for a retailer to receive their return before issuing a refund creates financial stress, rising to 77% among shoppers under 35 and parents. And 16% of shoppers under 35 returned something in the past year specifically because they needed the money back for bills.

It reaches well past budget shoppers, too. Refund stress is a majority at every income level, including 54% of households earning $100K or more. And 87% say the economy makes a guaranteed full refund especially important, echoing the guarantee shoppers said they’d consider paying for at checkout.

Waiting for a refund creates financial stress

Waiting for a refund creates financial stress

Strongly or somewhat agree

Strongly or somewhat agree

All online shoppers

All online shoppers

63%

63%

Ages 18 to 34

Ages 18 to 34

77%

77%

Parents

Parents

77%

77%

Returned something to cover bills

Returned something to cover bills

Past year. Note the shorter scale.

Past year. Note the shorter scale.

All online shoppers

All online shoppers

9%

9%

Ages 18 to 34

Ages 18 to 34

16%

16%

This isn’t only a budget-shopper problem. Refund stress is a majority at every income level, including 54% of households earning $100K or more.

This isn’t only a budget-shopper problem. Refund stress is a majority at every income level, including 54% of households earning $100K or more.

This isn’t only a budget-shopper problem. Refund stress is a majority at every income level, including 54% of households earning $100K or more.

This isn’t only a budget-shopper problem. Refund stress is a majority at every income level, including 54% of households earning $100K or more.

Waiting for a refund creates financial stress, by household income

Waiting for a refund creates financial stress, by household income

Base: 1,921 US adults who shopped online in the past six months. Strongly or somewhat agree.

Base: 1,921 US adults who shopped online in the past six months. Strongly or somewhat agree.

Under $50K

Under $50K

74%

74%

$50K to $74K

$50K to $74K

70%

70%

$75K to $99K

$75K to $99K

67%

67%

$100K or more

$100K or more

54%

54%

The dashed line marks 50%. Every income group is above it.

The dashed line marks 50%. Every income group is above it.

87%

87%

say the economy makes a guaranteed full refund especially important. That’s why the guarantee matters as much as the speed.

say the economy makes a guaranteed full refund especially important. That’s why the guarantee matters as much as the speed.

1. PYMNTS Intelligence, paycheck-to-paycheck research.

1. PYMNTS Intelligence, paycheck-to-paycheck research.

CONCLUSION

CONCLUSION

CONCLUSION

Your return policy is doing more selling than you think

Your return policy is doing more selling than you think

Your return policy is doing more selling than you think

From the first click to the refund, shoppers are asking whether a store will keep its word. They’ll pay for a clear answer, and the stores that give one get a better shot at the sale, a clearer read on why things really come back, and fewer customers stuck with something they didn’t want.

What to do this holiday season

What to do this holiday season

What to do this holiday season

One move for each stage of the journey, plus one that runs across all of it.

One move for each stage of the journey, plus one that runs across all of it.

Show your return policy and holiday return deadline before shoppers reach checkout.

Show your return policy and holiday return deadline before shoppers reach checkout.

Offer optional protection at checkout that covers returns and delivery issues.

Offer optional protection at checkout that covers returns and delivery issues.

Take return shipping costs off the shopper.

Take return shipping costs off the shopper.

Start refunds when the return is on its way, not when it arrives.

Start refunds when the return is on its way, not when it arrives.

Show every post-purchase cost before the shopper pays.

Show every post-purchase cost before the shopper pays.

SHOPPER TRUST SCORE

SHOPPER TRUST SCORE

SHOPPER TRUST SCORE

How does your store measure up?

How does your store measure up?

How does your store measure up?

Five questions, one for each stage of the journey. Your answers are compared with what 1,921 shoppers told us.

Five questions, one for each stage of the journey. Your answers are compared with what 1,921 shoppers told us.

0–30

0–30

Trust at risk

Trust at risk

40–70

40–70

Building trust

Building trust

80–100

80–100

Trust leader

Trust leader

Calculate your shopper trust score

Compare how you’ve optimized your shopper experience with the results we saw from our survey data. It takes about a minute.

Most of my customers are

ABOUT THE RESEARCH

ABOUT THE RESEARCH

ABOUT THE RESEARCH

Methodology

Methodology

Methodology

This survey was conducted online within the United States by The Harris Poll on behalf of Seel from October 22 to 24, 2026, among 1,921 US adults ages 18 and older who have shopped online in the past six months. Results are weighted to be representative. The margin of error is ±2.7 percentage points.

This survey was conducted online within the United States by The Harris Poll on behalf of Seel from October 22 to 24, 2026, among 1,921 US adults ages 18 and older who have shopped online in the past six months. Results are weighted to be representative. The margin of error is ±2.7 percentage points.

CONDUCTED BY

CONDUCTED BY

CONDUCTED BY

The Harris Poll

The Harris Poll

The Harris Poll

FIELDWORK

FIELDWORK

FIELDWORK

Oct 22–24, 2026

Oct 22–24, 2026

Oct 22–24, 2026

SAMPLE

SAMPLE

SAMPLE

1,921 US adults

1,921 US adults

1,921 US adults

MARGIN OF ERROR

MARGIN OF ERROR

MARGIN OF ERROR

±2.7 pts

±2.7 pts

±2.7 pts

Insurance benefits are provided by Seel Insurance Inc. or Arch Specialty Insurance Company, and policies are offered and administered by Seel Insurance Services, Inc., depending on jurisdiction and product availability. Coverage is subject to the terms, conditions, limitations, and exclusions of the applicable policy and may not be available in all jurisdictions. Carrier participation, eligibility, and product availability may vary by state in accordance with applicable laws and regulations.

|

|

© Seel

Insurance benefits are provided by Seel Insurance Inc. or Arch Specialty Insurance Company, and policies are offered and administered by Seel Insurance Services, Inc., depending on jurisdiction and product availability. Coverage is subject to the terms, conditions, limitations, and exclusions of the applicable policy and may not be available in all jurisdictions. Carrier participation, eligibility, and product availability may vary by state in accordance with applicable laws and regulations.

|

|

© Seel

Insurance benefits are provided by Seel Insurance Inc. or Arch Specialty Insurance Company, and policies are offered and administered by Seel Insurance Services, Inc., depending on jurisdiction and product availability. Coverage is subject to the terms, conditions, limitations, and exclusions of the applicable policy and may not be available in all jurisdictions. Carrier participation, eligibility, and product availability may vary by state in accordance with applicable laws and regulations.

|

|

© Seel

Insurance benefits are provided by Seel Insurance Inc. or Arch Specialty Insurance Company, and policies are offered and administered by Seel Insurance Services, Inc., depending on jurisdiction and product availability. Coverage is subject to the terms, conditions, limitations, and exclusions of the applicable policy and may not be available in all jurisdictions. Carrier participation, eligibility, and product availability may vary by state in accordance with applicable laws and regulations.

|

|

© Seel